Jump to content
CameraBag & Fotograf Forums
Doug Pardee

Supplied presets

Recommended Posts

Just thinking aloud about the supplied presets...

For the B&W presets, how about using a Filtered B&W with Amount=0 instead of Saturation? That would make it a tiny bit easier to add color filtration to those presets when desired.

Is there a reason that some of the B&W presets do the curve first and then the saturation, while others do the saturation first?

Have you considered including the 1-Hour Photo preset? Yeah, it's pretty close to a slightly-blurred version of the new B&W Films G 03, but G 03 is gentler on the bright highlights, which can reduce the impact of the result a bit.

Speaking of B&W presets, what's the difference between B&W Essentials and the new B&W Films? I get that the film presets with "G" in the name add grain, but otherwise they seem to me to be just more variations. And sometimes the variations are unclear -- there's not a lot of difference between B&W Essentials 08 and B&W Films N 01, between B&W Essentials 04 and B&W Films N 04, and between B&W Essentials 09 and B&W Films N 05.

Color Essentials 02 and 04 have separate Exposure, Contrast, and Saturation tools. Would they be simpler with a Multi-Tool? Or does the order somehow matter for those presets? Or maybe it'd be better to swap out the Contrast tool with Advanced Contrast using the default origin and method?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A lot of those differences (saturation before or after curve) is just based on what looked nicest on the test photos at the time. B+W Essentials has more variety, is a broad swath of different B+W styles. B+W Films are all just gamma curve and saturation (and grain in the G set), so for example they'll never raise the black level like some of the B+W styles do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×